Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, Liver, 14 oz. Pouch

I had originally bought this product back in 2022-2023 and i'd be lying if i said the quality has gone down. I saw a review saying they changed the formula and the texture was off but unless my other bag was just stale, these feel super similar, softer if anything! They cut super easily, they have never given my dog a stomach ache+ She absolutely loves them! Some complain about the smell but i prefer it, it helps my dog focus on training and the smell left on your hands goes away after 2-3 washes so it's not a big deal. The one thing i do wish they had was an option to buy in bulk for a slightly cheaper price haha. Or just a larger size bag because it feels like i'm going through so much so quickly since i'm currently training my dog haha Overall super good quality, they last a while, they're not super expensive and they look like kibble so its easy for me to mix her food in a ziplock bag with them so they get the smell! lmao

My dog loves these treats. They are the only training treat I buy. Good quality, perfect size for training and also treat dispensing toys.

I could probably get my dogs to do my taxes if I gave them enough of these treats. They will do anything for one of these little morsels. So I use them to train them to do stuff I want them to do. They smell fresh, my dog's say they are clearly palatable, and they are nutritious . They are not sticky or stinky, they smell quite nice actually. You have to keep them sealed though or they will go stale. But I put them in a small zip lock bag when I remove them from the bag, that way they stay fresh. And they stay fresh in the bag for a long time. Try them out. Who knows, you might have the next juggling dog. After a few treats.

We did Zukes and a few others prior to switching to these. The ingredients are better with little cost difference. They are perfect for training as we are constantly working with our pup to learn new things and stay mentally active. It is just unfortunate that the price fluctuates so much. I originally purchased them just shy of $8 with our most recent purchase being $8.91 and now they are $10.09. We tried the salmon as they tend to be cheaper but the smell is aweful. With the current price it is actually making it more cost effective to simply buy 4 lbs of ground turkey at Sams Club at $13 to cook and store. He also tends to get more excited for that anyway. I will stick with these for now just because of the convenience factor but I don't know how much more these treats are going to be worth it if the price keeps going up.

These treats are perfect for rewarding Fido without adding too many calories. My dog cannot be given any treats larger than a piece of kibble or he will immediately start about hiding it in my bed, sofa, chair…you get the picture. So, these are perfect because I don’t find them in my blankets :) he loves them so much he will literally eat through the Amazon delivery bag if he smells them in there! If you are sensitive to texture and sticky fingers like me, these are perfect because there is no residue on your fingers after touching them. Hooray!

Dogs love them, smell and taste good to them. Easy to fill pockets for a walk.

These are perfect for smaller dogs who can't chew well because of missing or loose teeth! They are on the smaller and softer side, so either the dogs can chew slightly or just swallow! Also they are more nutritious than other treats.

My dog LOVES these. She is reactive, so we can't really take her on walks or anything, so the way we exercise her is by teaching and practicing tricks. Because these have a low calorie count, I don't worry about giving her too many. We also use them to stuff a kong toy or a snuffle mat and she cannot get enough. They are reasonably priced (we have it on subscribe and save because we use a lot of them) but it is a good size bag for the money. They have never made my dog sick, and she seems to digest them well. Definitely a great option for a little snack for the pup!

Puppy loves them kids not so keen

I always have to check fat content on dog treats as my dog is very sensitive to fatty dog foods and treats(pancreatitis) usually the low fat ones are dry and hard and she dislikes them.. these are 4% fat which is perfect, soft ans chewy. She LOVES them! Win win happy doggy happy mommy Good quality treats for a decent price! Also the bag has a-lot in it ; 360 treats Definitely recommend!!!

These have been great for training as we have considered them high value treats because she absolutely loves these treats versus others we have used.

Not my favourite training treat, these are very hard to break into smaller pieces, and tend to have a large ingredient list with hidden ingredients

I originally got 3 different flavors of Tricky Trainers from a pet store which then discontinued them. Because my dog liked them, I thought I would try the Liver pouch carried on Amazon. The package was slightly larger than the pet store version, so the price wasn't quite so hard to take. Also, the tidbits (on the small size) were very fresh on arrival. There is one other treat that my dog absolutely loves (it needs to be refrigerated due to a meat component) so the Tricky Trainers are # 2 on his list. I have actually used them to train him to follow basic commands, so it makes both of us happy. I'm not an expert, but I would think these would be better for somewhat smaller dogs.